BRONX, NY — Only twenty miles separate the campuses of Ithaca College and Cortland University in the far trenches of upstate New York, two schools with tradition and football programs that compete at the NCAA Division III level.
Less popular from the more known Division I power houses such as Georgia, Utah, Alabama, UCLA, Notre Dame, and Miami, the top six programs in the latest College Football Playoff rankings. They get more acclaim and exposure nationally on lucrative television contracts, huge alumni support, and sponsors. Head coaches, too, with hefty multi-million contracts, eye-raising buy-out clauses and NIL/recruitment budgets that far surpass an average American’s working salary.
At Yankee Stadium Saturday afternoon there was the contrast. Budgets not as thick, scholar-athletes nowhere of the magnitude or known names of their Division I counterparts, but it was college football. The 67th Annual Cortaca Jug game between the Ithaca College Bombers and SUNY Cortland Red Dragons and this latest matchup marked the third time ever at Yankee Stadium.
The storied rivalry between Ithaca and Cortland drew 31,118 fans to the Bronx Saturday afternoon for the fourth-highest attended Division III football game ever – Image Credit: Alan Bautista/Latino Sports
Ithaca, seeking to win the jug a second consecutive year in a game presented by Visions Credit Union and the New York Yankees, made for a solid fit and similar theme of history to Yankee Stadium.
The two schools opposed each other for the 84th time. Their first matchup came in 1930, with Cortland owning the jug, 12-0 The hardware was introduced in 1959 by the captains of both teams. As the story goes, team captains Tom Decker (Cortland) and Dick Carmean (Ithaca) drove to a nearby town of Homer, NY, stopped at a yard sale and purchased a $2 jug from a local farmer with the concept of it being a trophy.
Two friends then painted the jug blue, red, and white in honor of both the schools’ colors, a jug that remains and is hardly tarnished as the first one. The rest is history.
In the first ever matchup between Ithaca and Cortland in 1930, the Red Dragons won 12-0, but Ithaca would win the following season, 12-6 – Image Credit: Ithaca College Athletics
Cortland would close the first half on Saturday leading 23-13. Back-and-forth on the stadium turf they went on passing and running plays as both teams combined for 477 yards of offense.
The second half began a contrast until Cortland took control on consecutive touchdowns midway in the fourth.
In the end, to take home the jug it was all about the defense as Cortland won 30-23 on a fourth-down sack after their lead was cut to seven points.
George Gjelaj calls game! 👏@CortlandFB pic.twitter.com/U9DxahqxhV
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) November 14, 2026
The Red Dragons (10-0) now head to the NCAA Division III Tournament and await their seeding of a first round game next Saturday at noon with either Amherst College or Bridgewater St. University as their next opponent.
It’s their version of the CFB Playoff system that only seems fitting for Division 1 powerhouse schools.
Ithaca (7-3) concludes a disappointing season that had projections of being one of those playoff teams.
In Saturday’s loss vs. Cortland at Yankee Stadium, Ithaca quarterback Michael Reed passed for 283 yards on 16-for-24 attempts and three touchdowns – Image Credit: Alan Bautista/Latino Sports
Since 1959, half of the games (32) have come down to a single possession and two ended in overtime (2005 and 2006). Ithaca’s longest winning streak is nine games while Cortland’s is seven.
Also there is significance of this game played in major venues including MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, the home of the NFL’s Giants and Jets and at Yankee Stadium. Attendance figures are boosted with fan and alumni support of both schools who want a crack at the jug.
So much so that this rivalry owns the two highest crowds in Division III history—45,161 at MetLife in 2019 and 40,232 at Yankee Stadium in 2022.
Before Saturday’s win over Ithaca at Yankee Stadium, the Red Dragons earned an automatic bid into the playoffs after finishing 7-0 in league play to capture their sixth straight Empire 8 title – Image Credit: Alan Bautista/Latino Sports
On Saturday, 31,118 battled the cold elements and witnessed Ithaca, coming off a 14-10 loss last week at home against Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, thus missing a chance at the Liberty League title due to a late third quarter touchdown which resulted in that decisive score.
The Bombers failed to compile 300 yards of offense with 292 in the loss, and quarterback Michael Reed recorded the team’s only touchdown. A week later a tough Cortland defense kept him from doing damage in the end zone.
Ranked No. 9 of 10 in the NCAA’s NPI, aka Power Index, are those Red Dragons. Junior quarterback Mike Rescigno was named the inaugural Larry Czarnecki Cortaca Jug Most Valuable Player after accounting for 367 yards and four touchdowns. He ran for 150 yards and had two scores while throwing for 217 yards and two touchdowns.
He had rushed for 902 yards with 10 touchdowns this season and threw for 1591 yards with 16 more TDs prior to Saturday, establishing a school record for a quarterback.
Mike Rescigno joins Brad Erceg to reflect on winning the Cortaca Jug at Yankee Stadium, as well as winning the 2026 Larry Czarnecki Award. pic.twitter.com/XYomqCuJj0
— YES Network (@YESNetwork) November 14, 2026
“We got play makers all over the place,” said Rescigno. “They made me look good today. It started in August, we executed right. If you could give it (the MVP trophy) to a group, give it to the defense. Now we won ourselves a whole another season that we are all looking forward to.”
With momentum now on their side, the jug ultimately went to Cortland to continue their season, and it was accomplished at Yankee Stadium where it likely will be defended by the Red Dragons again a year from now.
Rich Mancuso is a senior writer for Latino Sports, who covers Major League Baseball (MLB), Boxing, and Major League Soccer (MLS). You can follow him on X/Twitter @Ring786 and to stay in the know on all boxing, watch Rich’s weekly show, Keep It In The Ring, available on his Youtube channel.
Follow us on Social Media for updates and exclusive content
Instagram: @latinosportsoficial
Twitter: @latinosports
TikTok: @latino.sports
Facebook: Latino Sports
