NEW YORK, NY — Syracuse and St. John’s. The Orange and Red Storm. New York’s teams.
There was a time in which the rivalry between Syracuse and St. John’s, the two charter programs of the Big East Conference, was must-watch television each meeting.
Some years a highly demanded ticket across New York, too, if lucky enough to get your hands on it. Box office.
However, since the formation of the “new” league in 2013-14 creating the current landscape of the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) and Big East, all of that has changed, with not many opportunities for Syracuse and St. John’s to go toe-to-toe.

The Syracuse Orange and St. John’s Red Storm met for the 93rd time in the history of the two programs Sunday night at Madison Square Garden, a series between the two charter Big East Conference programs that dates back to 1912 – Image Credit: St. John’s Men’s Basketball
A handful of occasions basically as Sunday night’s Red Storm 79-62 win over the Orange at Madison Square Garden was just the fifth regular season Syracuse-St. John’s matchup since 2014-2015.
And during that span, with the Johnnies up 5-0 in the series, both sides have had their fair share of disappointing campaigns causing fans to be drawn in less.
More so of recently for the Orange than the No. 13 ranked Red Storm when comparing year on year success.
Since 2020-2021
Syracuse: 102-92, 1 NCAA Tournament appearance (2021)
St. John’s: 136-66, 2 NCAA Tournament appearances (2025 & 2024)
Yet Sunday had all the feels of a blast into the past. First off, as 16,431 were in attendance, sitting courtside at “The World’s Most Famous Arena” was Dominican basketball icon and St. John’s legend Felipe López, former four-time MLB All-Star José Reyes, well known across NYC for his playing days with the Mets as well as Mets Hall of Famer John Franco.
Once a Johnnie, Always a Johnnie
Felipe López in attendance for Syracuse vs. No. 13 St. John’s at Madison Square Garden
Visit https://t.co/rMmlz13ps7#SJUBB #LatinoSports #WeAreStJohns #NYC #RedStorm #CollegeHoops #NewYork #Basketball pic.twitter.com/mwFoNjYfzO
— Latino Sports (@LatinoSports) November 16, 2026
Oh, and not to mention, a recognizable Syracuse alum Carmelo Anthony who has his imprints all over the program’s history books in upstate New York, leading the Orange to winning its first-ever NCAA National Championship title in 2003.
Anthony, 42, inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in September of 2025, was in the building to watch his son Kiyan, a sophomore guard for Syracuse make his MSG debut, an arena he is all too familiar with from attending Knicks games for years while his dad was the star across the Big Apple.
Listed at six-five, the product of Christ The King and Long Island Lutheran High School, Anthony, 19, would go on to rattle off 17 points on 7/12 shooting from the field—two shy of tying his career-high in points—to go along with four assists and two rebounds.
Kiyan going crazy with his 3rd and-1 of the half! 🔥🔥 pic.twitter.com/TouYmXKuYE
— Syracuse Men’s Basketball (@Cuse_MBB) November 16, 2026
“I think he’s going to have a tremendous career. He’s not going to be his dad, very few people are in all of basketball, but I think he’s going to have a great career at Syracuse,” said St. John’s head coach Rick Pitino, a fellow Naismith Hall of Famer, inducted in 2013.
Tremendous would be a Syracuse-St. John’s rivalry renewed although realistically it may take some time for players and younger fans in this current era to legitimately experience it, like those late 1980’s-early 1990’s wars or at some points in the early 2000’s.
Rick Pitino on future of Syracuse series: “We’re not going up to the Dome. If they want to come to the Garden… McNamara’s going to turn this program around… Syracuse will bring like UConn. MSG will be split in half, because their fans used to be just like UConn, unfortunately.” pic.twitter.com/2V4G5ct5x0
— The Field of 68 (@TheFieldOf68) November 16, 2026
“We were aware of it, coach (Pitino) had mentioned it to us to the tune that he said ‘we don’t lose at home. That’s our goal, not to lose at home,’” noted graduate forward Keyshawn Hall, a transfer out of Auburn. “That was the main thing. We knew they were going to have a lot of fans come out, but we knew we just had to stick to the gameplan, play hard, play physical, because we know they want to come in here and win too, because they’re a New York team, too. They think this is their arena, too, so we had to show them it’s ours.”
In the win to move St. John’s to 4-0 on the young College Hoops season, Hall dropped 18 points, with seven boards and five assists while his teammate Tounde Yessoufou finished with 19 points and 14 rebounds.
Tounde slam gets @TheGarden ROCKING 🔴⛈️ pic.twitter.com/xdE0tqzsPY
— St. John's Men’s Basketball (@StJohnsBBall) November 16, 2026
Said the sophomore guard Yessoufou, landing in Queens after transferring from Baylor this offseason: “Honestly, I would say that we still have a lot to learn in terms of playing together. We’ve only been together for a short amount of time, but I feel like once we build that chemistry, we can beat anybody in the nation. That’s the expectation. Right now, though, it’s just one day at a time.”
He added: “Each practice matters, as we saw from the first half, we just take it for what it is. We aren’t thinking too far into the future—just focusing on what is coming next. Right now, what’s next is practice tomorrow and that’s it.”
Robert Rizzo is the editor of Latino Sports. You can follow him on X/Twitter @RobertRiz994 and reach him at RobertRiz994@gmail.com.
Follow us on Social Media for updates and exclusive content
Instagram: @latinosportsoficial
Twitter: @latinosports
TikTok: @latino.sports
Facebook: Latino Sports
